FDR and the New Deal: Programs, Timeline, Did It Work? 3 Surprising Ways the New Deal Affects You Today

Note: As America is about to begin another presidential administration that will, as is already noted, challenge some of the excellent on-going New Deal programs established by President Franklin Roosevelt in the 1930s, I wanted to share information about some of these profound programs. Many of them were meant specifically to help the poor and/or those overall who struggled from the impact of the depression in the 1920’s and 30’s.

The programs were, in addition to assisting millions of Americans, also a considered a challenge by America’s wealthy corporate, political and military elite many of whom cried “socialism”.  Yet this label of “socialism” was far from true. It was largely a “mixed” economic system promoted by New Dealers. It included both public monies being appropriately used to assist and protect the masses of the people along with  on-going capitalist ventures in the private sector.  The New Deal programs then and today probably saved and continue to save American capitalism.  As author Kimberly Amadeo notes below:

Even today, New Deal programs soften the extremes of the business cycle. Before the New Deal (1797-1929), there were 33 major economic downturns, 22 recessions, four depressions and seven bank runs and panics. They impacted 60 of the 132 years covered. Recessions were more severe than they are today because there weren’t the New Deal federal agencies to control corruption, fraud, and exploitation.

The New Deal was, nevertheless, far from perfect. Some refer to it as affirmative action for whites as the programs were mostly not equitable in terms of services and opportunities for the Black community in education, agriculture, housing and other job opportunities, etc. Nor was there protection and services offered for farm workers across the country.  In many instances, the programs were not equitable thanks largely to the discriminatory/racist staff throughout the country that implemented the programs and not necessarily because of the actual legislation. (This scenario is echoed by one of my colleagues at Tuskegee University in Alabama regarding agriculture policies. He noted that “the closer you are to the farmer the harder it is to implement policy” – and this is because of on-going “white” racist staff in agriculture offices throughout the South.)

The New Deal programs, however, need to be continued as well as improved upon to be more inclusive to protect American individuals and society overall.

Heather Gray

FDR and the New Deal: Programs, Timeline, Did It Work?
3 Surprising Ways the New Deal Affects You Today
November 08, 2016
The Balance
Definition: The New Deal was a promise made by Franklin D. Roosevelt to end the Great Depression. Americans, battered by 25% unemployment, Dust Bowl droughts, and four waves of bank failures, were ready for the government to be the champion and come to the rescue. The New Deal was a far cry from the previous “…hear-nothing, see-nothing, do-nothing Government,” derided by FDR in his 1936 Campaign speech.
Why Did FDR Propose the New Deal?
FDR’s predecessor, Herbert Hoover, didn’t do much to stop the Depression. He believed in a free market economy that would self-correct. He was also concerned that economic assistance would make people want to stop working. Hoover’s biggest concern was keeping the budget balanced. As the Depression wore on, government revenue fell. To keep from running a deficit, Hoover cut spending.
Even when Congress pressured Hoover to take action, he focused on stabilizing businesses. He believed that this would trickle down to the average person.
Instead, the Depression worsened. FDR proposed the New Deal to reverse this downward spiral. The goal was relief, recovery, and reform, for those who were hardest hit. (Source: Collin County Community College District, The Great Depression and the New Deal)
New Deal Programs
FDR launched the New Deal in three waves from 1933-1939.
Congress passed these 47 programs to stabilize the U.S. financial system, provide  relief to farmers and jobs to the unemployed, and build private-public  partnerships to boost manufacturing. Here’s a timeline of when they began and what they did.
  • Emergency Banking Act – March 9: FDR closed all banks as soon as he was inaugurated to stop bank runs. This Act allowed banks to reopen once  examiners found them to be financially secure.  Five thousand banks reopened in the next three days.
  • Government Economy Act – March 20: Cut the pay of government and military employees by 15%, and cut government spending by 25%. The $1 billion saved went to finance New Deal programs.
  • Beer-Wine Revenue Act – March 22: Ended Prohibition and taxed alcohol sales, raising federal revenue.
  • Civilian Conservation Corps – March 31: Hired 3 million workers over the next ten years to conserve public land by planting forests, building flood barriers and maintaining roads and trails.
  • Abandonment of Gold Standard – April 19: FDR stopped a run on the precious metal by ordering everyone to exchange all gold for dollars.
  • Federal Emergency Relief Act – May 12: Funded a wide variety of jobs in agriculture, the arts, construction, and education.
  • Agricultural Adjustment Act – May 12: Paid farmers to limit crops. Doubled crop prices by 1937. Overturned by Supreme Court in 1935 because it taxed processors, then gave funds to farmers. Was remedied in 1938.
  • Emergency Farm Mortgage Act – May 12:  Provided loans to save farms from foreclosure.
  • Tennessee Valley Authority Act – May 18: Built power stations in the Tennessee Valley, the poorest area in the nation.
  • Securities Act – May 27: Required corporations to provide information to investors before issuing stock.
  • Abrogation of Gold Payment Clause – June 5: The government no longer had to repay dollars with gold.
  • Home Owners Refinancing Act – June 13: Established the Home Owners Loan Corporation (HOLC), which refinanced mortgages to prevent foreclosures. It also provided additional capital to mortgage lenders. When it closed in 1935, it had refinanced one million homes (20% of all urban mortgages).
  • Glass-Steagall Banking Act – June 16: Separated investment banking from retail banking, which prevented banks from using depositors’ funds for risky investments. It gave regulation of retail banks to the Federal Reserve, prohibited bank sales of securities, and created the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). Repealed in 1999 by the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act.
  • National Industrial Recovery Act (NIRA) – June 16: Set up the Public Works Administration (PWA) to create public works jobs, like San Francisco’s Golden Gate Bridge and New York City’s Triborough Bridge. Created the National Recovery Administration to outlaw child labor, establish a minimum wage of $1.25, and limit the workday to eight hours. It gave trade unions the legal right to bargain with employers. It was declared unconstitutional in 1935.
  • Emergency Railroad Transportation Act – June 16: Attempted to coordinate the national railway systems, reduce duplication and improve profitability to railroad companies. It expired in 1935.
  • Civil Works Administration – November 8: Created 4 million higher-paying jobs in construction. Cities and towns had to add to the $400 million in federal funds. It was canceled in 1934 due to cost.
In 1934, conservative businessmen criticized the New Deal as for being too socialistic. Others, like Louisiana politician Huey Long, said it didn’t do enough for the poor. Nevertheless, FDR pushed for these additional programs:
  • Gold Reserve Act  – January 30: FDR prohibited private gold ownership. He increased the price of gold to $35 per ounce, up from $20.67 per ounce where it had been for 100 years. That nearly doubled the value of the gold held in Fort Knox from $4.033 billion to $7.348 billion, making the U.S. the world’s largest owner of gold.
  • National Housing Act – June 27: Established the Federal Housing Administration (FHA) which provides Federal insurance for mortgages.
  • Securities Exchange Act – Created the Securities and Exchange Commission, which regulates stocks and the stock market.
  • Federal Communications Act – Consolidated all federal regulation of telephone, telegraph, and radio communications under the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
In 1935, the Supreme Court struck down the National Industrial Recovery Act. Concerned that other programs would also be eliminated, FDR launched the second round of New Deal programs. These focused on providing more services for the poor, the unemployed and farmers. FDR spoke about helping the “…millions who never had a chance — men at starvation wages, women in sweatshops, children at looms.”
  • Soil Conservation & Domestic Allotment Act – February 26:   Paid farmers to plant soil-building crops,  like beans and grasses, to counteract the Dust Bowl.
  • Emergency Relief Appropriation – April 8: Replaced FERA and funded the new Works Progress Administration (WPA) with $5 million. It employed  8.5 million people to build bridges, roads, public buildings, public parks and airports. It paid artists to create 2,566 murals and 17,744 pieces of sculpture to decorate the public works.
  • Rural Electrification Act – May 20: Provided loans to farming cooperatives to generate electricity for their rural areas.
  • National Labor Relations Act /Wagner Act – July: Protected the rights of employees to organize and address working conditions, with or without a union, and created the National Labor Relations Board.
  • Resettlement Act:  Created Resettlement Administration (RA), which  trained  farmers, and administered farm debt adjustment activities. It bought ten million acres of submarginal farm land and paid farmers to convert it to pasture, preserves, or parks. It resettled farmers onto better land and taught them modern conservation and farming techniques.
  • Social Security Act (SSA) – August:  Created the Social Security Trust Fund and Administration to provides income to the elderly, the blind, the disabled and children in low-income families.
In 1937, FDR rolled out the Third New Deal. However, he was concerned about budget deficits, so did not fund it as strongly as the previous two.
  • Federal Security Agency – Administered Social Security, federal education funding, and food and drug safety. It was abolished in 1953. For more, see Timeline of the Great Depression.
Did It Work?
The table below shows clearly that the New Deal worked. After the first New Deal was launched, the economy grew 10.8% in 1934. When the second New Deal rolled out, the economy grew 8.9% in 1935 and 12.9% in 1936. After government spending was cut in 1937, the economy contracted 3.3%.

From 1932, the year before the New Deal, to 1941, when the U.S. entered the war, the debt only grew by $3 billion. The next year, defense spending quadrupled the amount added to the debt by a whopping $23 billion. The amount added tripled to $64 billion in 1943. If that much had been spent in the first year of the New Deal, it would have ended the Depression right there and then.

That disproves those who say the New Deal didn’t work because the Depression lasted for ten years.  They point out that defense spending on World War II was the only thing that ended the Depression. (Source: “The New Deal,” Roosevelt Forward.)

Even today, New Deal programs soften the extremes of the business cycle. Before the New Deal (1797-1929), there were 33 major economic downturns, 22 recessions, four depressions and seven bank runs and panics. They impacted 60 of the 132 years covered. Recessions were more severe than they are today because there weren’t the New Deal federal agencies to control corruption, fraud, and exploitation. For more, see Effects of the Great Depression.
Since WWII, there have been 11 recessions that impacted just ten out 60 years. They were milder than those before, thanks to the safety nets of the New Deal. (Source: “Forgetting the Why of the New Deal,” Consortium News.com. Beverly Bandler,”FDR and the New Deal.” pdf, 20 pp, August 27, 2012)
Could It Have Prevented World War II?
Consider this. FDR spent thirty times more in 1943 on the war than he did in 1933 on the New Deal. There was no resistance on war spending as there was on domestic spending. No one was worried about the budget deficit when the world was worried about Hitler’s military dominance. However, concerns about the budget deficit sabotaged the New Deal from ending the Depression’s global economic catastrophe. Why do military threats engender so much more public support than economic ones?

If FDR had spent as much on the New Deal in 1933 as he did in the war in 1943, it would have ended the Depression by creating jobs, demand, and economic growth. The Depression’s misery helped propel the German people to put the Nazis and Hitler in power. If FDR and the New Deal had ended the Depression in the early 1930s, the U.S. could have turned its resources sooner to helping its allies, Great Britain, and France. It would have at least shortened, if not prevented, World War II.
FDR and the New Deal Timeline
What Happened
1929 – Hoover became President. Stock market crash in October kicked off Depression. $1 billion surplus. Unemployment at 3.2%.
1930 – Congress passed the Smoot-Hawley tariff to protect jobs. Trading partners retaliated, driving world trade down 65%. The economy contracted 8.5%, unemployment rose to 8.7%. Another $1 billion surplus.
1931 – Fed raised rates to defend the gold standard, worsening depression. The economy contracted 6.4%, unemployment rose to 15.9%, and debt increased by $1 billion.
1932 – FDR campaigned on New Deal promises. The economy contracted 12.9%, and unemployment rose to 23.6%. Lower revenues added. $3 billion to debt.
1933 – FDR took office, immediately launched 16 programs in First New Deal. Added $3 billion to debt. Depression started to lift, as economy only contracted 1.3%. Unemployment rose to 24.9%.
1934 – Economy grew 10.8%, and unemployment fell to 21.7%. $5 billion added to the debt.
1935 – FDR added 2nd New Deal, adding $2 billion to debt. The economy grew 8.9% and unemployment fell to 20.1%.
1936 – Economy grew, 12.9%, reducing unemployment to 16.9%. $5 billion added to the debt.
1937 – FDR started 2nd term. Fearing budget deficit, he cut spending only adding $3 billion to debt, despite rolling out Third New Deal. The economy grew 5.1% and unemployment fell to 14.3%.
1938 – No more New Deal legislation was passed, and spending was cut., so only $1 billion added to the debt. Unemployment rose to 19%, the economy shrank 3.3%.
1939 – Dust Bowl drought ended. U.S. spent to build up the military as Europe entered WWII, adding $3 billion to debt. The economy grew 8.0%, unemployment fell to 17.2%.
1940 – Unemployment fell to 14.6% as U.S. started the draft. FDR won reelection. Assisted Great Britain by sending weapons, adding $3 billion to debt. The economy grew 8.8%.
1941 – FDR began his third term. Japan attacked Pearl Harbor in December. U.S. entered WWII. Spending eliminated Depression, adding $6 billion to debt. The economy grew 17.7%, unemployment fell to 9.9%.
1942 – Unemployment fell to 4.7% while the economy grew 18.9%. War spending added $23 billion to debt.
1943 – War added $64 billion to debt. GDP growth was 17.0%, unemployment fell to 1.9%. Italy surrendered.
1944 – War added $64 billion to debt. GDP growth was 8.0%, unemployment was 1.2%. The Bretton-Woods Agreement made the dollar the global currency.
1945 – FDR died in April. Truman became President. Added $58 billion to debt. Germany surrendered in May. Truman dropped a nuclear bomb in August. Japan surrendered in September, ending WWII. The economy contracted 1.0% and unemployment edged up to 1.9% as soldiers returned home.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s